>>499022>i think that mamdani represents an authentic expression of a desire for socialismOh wow, this is actually
way worse analysis than I thought it would be.
This is barely even a critique of Mamdani; you essentially mistake his
audience and the public image presented by his electoral campaign for his actual character and role within the DNC. No, to be clear, those things are charades. And, even forgiving my nitpick that social democracy is not an actual form of socialism, it stands evident that there
is no social democratic movement of any significance whatsoever within the United States today; the DNC itself has institutionally rejected any facsimile of even so much as returning to FDR-style compromise, let alone "Nordic model" economic policy. The DNC and GOP are fundamentally state institutions, and as state institutions the real interests which they always represent are those of the
real state, which, in America today, is the military & corporate state of rentiers, finance capitalists, and plunderers from which the American oligarchs of today emerge. While there is street-level desire for real reform, the democratization of wealth, and the empowerment of workers in the United States, the function of "socialists" like Mamdani, Sanders, AOC, etc. is to suck the life out of any socialist, anti-zionist, anti-imperialist movement and create the illusion that today's American labor movement can and
does operate within the institutional parameters set by the most bloodthirsty robber barons alive in the world today. Even if the goal was a "compromise" like social democracy, it would still never emerge under conditions where these figures are treated as legitimate, because attaining even a "compromise" requires some form of pressure from outside of institutions bought and controlled by the American corporate state.
What many critics of Mamdani have done, and I believe were probably right to do (and some examples which spring to mind immediately are Nerdeen Kiswani and BadEmpanada), was that they treated Mamdani's candidacy with an air of "cautious optimism," pointing out, from a perspective of material analysis, why such a candidacy through the DNC was unlikely to achieve any positive results, while still offering "hope" that they were wrong, and approval of the electoral messaging
even though you could tell they knew it was a charade, there was a decisive humoring of it. This positioned them very well to (correctly) be ruthless in criticism leveled after the election towards Mamdani's betrayal of the anti-genocide movement he ran on, and to share in the disappointment of Mamdani's supporters in a way which underlines just how fake and disconnected Mamdani's sycophants are. They also have managed to demonstrate how a simple materialist understanding of politics, and political parties and the financial interests behind them, yields better predictions… and all of this was done without starting from a public position of bitterness or spite or aloofness. When they discuss Mamdani's betrayal of the anti-genocide movement, of the opposition to the abduction of college students by the government, or the opposition to war, they are sharing the discontentment of the public who once had hopes in Mamdani.