[ home / overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / b / WRK / hobby / tech / edu / ga / ent / music / 777 / posad / i / a / lgbt / R9K / dead ] [ meta ]

/leftypol/ Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internets about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Captcha
Tor Only

Flag
File
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

Matrix   IRC Chat   Mumble


File: 1789495305984.png ( 365.49 KB , 598x540 , ClipboardImage.png )

 No.499022

I told y'all this mf was a sheepdog but nooooo nobody ever listens to the ultra
>>

 No.499023

>>499022
I for one have always felt the same. He's a democrat, isn't he?
>>

 No.499024

I won't fall for it again. I didn't believe he was good (ran as DNC after all), but wanted to give him a chance anyway on some level.  In the past, there were times when I wasn't paying close enough attention, when I might not have recognized the pattern which has repeated in a case like this, but it's very clear to me now.
>>

 No.499025

I hope Aaron Mate will pull his head out of his ass and stop defending this rat already.
>>

 No.499026

>>499025
Him and a few others - I think it's fairly certain that they'll lose any remaining false hope in MamDNC, but I wish they'd do it sooner rather than later.
>>

 No.499030

LEFT/RIGHT CALIPHATE DENILE/FUTILE

GOOD COP BAD COP POLITICS INSIDE YOUR EVERY MOVE

GO 27 DAYS WITHOUT MEDIA & FEEL … JUST FEEL WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT

12x12=

Thhh Vs Shhh
>>

 No.499047

>surely it's the faggots on the circus stage who actively define the show's script
You are a uyghur.
>>

 No.499152

File: 1790053701580.jpg ( 71.13 KB , 485x412 , delete this.jpg )

https://x.com/KlonnyPin_Gosch/status/2102156169179431023
ParaPower Mapping - Breaking: Mamdani reveals he will be steering clear of anti-Netanyahu protests in NYC, completing Millennial Obama transformation into anti-mvmt politics mayor in record time. Couple days later, he hangs out with the guy that signs all of Bibi's babybomb checks.
>>

 No.499225

https://www.instagram.com/p/DdsFK2VspXM/?hl=en
Palestinian Youth Movement NYC is now (FINALLY!) calling out Mamdani directly - I wonder if they'll stick to it or if they'll accept a BS apology.
>>

 No.499252

File: 1790406198807.png ( 2.45 MB , 1440x1800 , ClipboardImage.png )

>>

 No.499257

Kavernacle touches on this phenomenon here - the new party line of Hasan Piker & the DSA "left" is that principled candidates must team up with genocidal zionist losers if they want to win elections and then do nothing.
>>

 No.499347

File: 1790752753699.jpg ( 89.39 KB , 531x597 , twitter September 30 2026 ….jpg )

Zohran coming in to *checks notes* finally crack down on the terrible antisemitism crisis in New York City.
>>

 No.499348

>>499347
According to the Torah and Catholic /Orthodox Christian understanding of Scripture, the State of Israel has no right to exist. According to their own Prophets, they weren't supposed to return to the land of their own accord.
>>

 No.499349

>>499348
>they weren't supposed to return to the land of their own accord.
Which is funny because there was always a Jewish population remaining there even after the majority converted to Islam and Christianity. The whole exile narrative was nonsense, even before getting into why it's nonsense according to scripture. Jews lived there, they just spoke Arabic (as opposed to Yiddish, German, Polish, English, Russian, Spanish, French, constructed Modern Hebrew, etc.) and didn't dress in the fashions of European nobility.
>>

 No.499350

>>499349
The verses talk about when "all Israel will be saved". In their eschatology it is God who brings them back in full. Of course there was always a remnant left after every exile, but the point is they were supposed to wait for God to bring them back. Now they say it was promised thousands of years ago, but that was a conditional promise that was broken first when the northern kingdom split from Judah. Then came the several exiles for disobedience. It's their book and they don't even know it.
>>

 No.499367

>>499347
Huh, I live thousands of miles from this mayor and any Jews so I don't get it, but this guy in vidrel claims this move angered the NY knights of zion. The thing is, Israel State generates and promotes the spread of antisemitism with every means at their disposal. Without it they can't justify their existence or carry out their broader goals. Antisemitism is the State's bread and butter.
>>

 No.499382

File: 1790978450227.png ( 250.16 KB , 1220x1501 , Screenshot_20261002-175748….png )

>>

 No.499424

Mamdani:
>I can't attend or even encourage protests against a wanted war criminal I said I'd arrest if he entered NYC!
Also Mamdani:
>I must attend a victimhood party for genocidal zionists who believe everyone else in New York is subhuman, I have no choice, I owe it to my demographic of bloodthirsty Jewish supremacists!
>Gets booed by bloodthirsty Jewish supremacists
>This calls for another crackdown on Columbia students! Divestment is racism!
>>

 No.499428

Noah Samsen on Mamdani Theo Von interview.
>>

 No.499433

>>499022
atp we should begin issuing a 6-pointed star medal for all the hordes of libtarded subhumans with an "at least you did something" inscription on it. Don't worry gais tho they know how Bernito La$$alini could still win and finally bring about socialism with national characteristics into every suburbistan of AmeriKKKa don't foken ask them whos payin doe kek
>>

 No.499470

>>499022
This is why Im so grateful I dont get involved in politics like yall do  You still think that anyone genuine can stand a chance to win and actualluly implement justice.
>>

 No.499474

>>499470
>You still think that anyone genuine can stand a chance to win
Electorally? No I don't.
>>

 No.499499

>>499470
>xir still thinks there are winners in shows
ngmi
>>

 No.499501

Why Mamdani is in a Islamic lens/frame? ISLAM/MUSLIM is about unifying desert tribes of the  MIDDLE EAST in a inverted elite Scythian/Uzbek "silk road politics" eon/epoch weave …

DECONSTRUCT PEACEFULLY & LOGICALLY ANY CALIPHATE STARTUPS IN YER ZONE!
>>

 No.499505

>>499501
This is more of a /posad/ post, my dude.
>>

 No.499761

How it's going…

Mamdani Partners With Israeli Surveillance Company
Anti-Zionist mayor of New York City has finally done something to help Palestine as he promised: given a $750k contract to an Israeli surveillance company so that people in NYC get a taste of what it's like to live under Israeli oppression!
>>

 No.499762

i truly do not understand leftoids and i never will
anyone who thinks that mamdani is a "traitor" or a "rat" is just fucking stupid full stop
even those who act like they knew that he was really a fake leftist from the start have lost the plot
>>499047
>surely it's the faggots on the circus stage who actively define the show's script
shameful how this obvious shit needs to be spelled out

plenty of the people who voted for mamdani (you know, the hundreds of thousands of people who arent terminally online freaks) knew exactly what they to expect, and they voted anyways, because what else are they supposed to do?
somewhere in NYC, there is a dull and witless millennial moron who works as a cashier and hasnt opened a book since high school, who groks more about the nature of capitalist politics and how the capitalist state functions than a lot of you uyghers do
what the fuck did you people expect?
where the fuck did you get your political education from?
>>

 No.499763

>>499762
>guy who uses the word "leftoids" """agrees""" with Leftcom poster who basically said nothing, disagrees with everything ITT except this banal non-statement which was so vacuous and obvious that everyone else ignored it
Gee I wonder if this guy is replying to himself.
>>

 No.499764

>>499763
this is all you have, isn't it?
are you even human anymore?
>>

 No.499766

>>499764
No you don't understand cringe gay leftoid!
Discussing things is reactoid!
Everyone pay attention to my very important posts where I say shit everyone else already knows and act mad that these fucking leftoid nazoid burgeroids dared to speak ill of a zionist DNC shill!
Don't they know material conditions, capitalism bad, etc.?!
Stupidoid leftoid x-oid y-oid so-and-so-oid yadayadayada
*juggles rubber Mussolini-inspired asshole & dildo novelty toy set with tongue*

Am I doing it right?
>>

 No.499768

>>499766
what exactly is your point? do you think that i'm defending mamdani or something?
also, why do you have to act like a retarded faggot in order to make such an argument?
>>

 No.499772

>>499768
>do you think that i'm defending mamdani or something?
No, I think you're making an ultimately vapid criticism of criticism of Mamdani which aims to highlight the futility of said criticisms, but which ultimately misunderstands the criticisms themselves because feeling smarter than others is more important to you than actually understanding anything. Because of this flaw in your comprehension, you end up making the most futile critique of all, a critique of critiques based on assumptions about those critiques which are only assumed by you out of your own misplaced intellectual narcissism. Do better!
>>

 No.499774

>>499772
im saying that we need to make better criticisms of mamdani
because most if not all of the criticism towards him is from the standpoint of capitalist politics
therefore my argument is actually that leftists have a duty to consciously and explicitly put forward an alternative to capitalist politics through their discourse

ironically youre making a very empty take that focuses almost entirely on superficial characteristics and then compares that to what you believe le bad people who say le bad things say
from what i can tell you just skimmed what i wrote, saw language that triggered your redditized heuristics, and then got angry
and then you suddenly chimped the fuck out for reasons that i cant fathom
your emotional dysregulation is embarassing, do better
>>

 No.499779

>>499774
>we need to make better criticisms of mamdani
I don't disagree, but let's hear it.
>>

 No.499784

>>499779
Ziohran is in the same side as platner, who raped children. Ziohran escort netanyahu. New york city wages decrease since ziohran get in https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/recent-trends-in-personal-income-wage-inequality/ . Ziohran freeze worker pension while bailing small business. Ziohran support trump and shake his hand. Same people who work for platner work for ziohran. Ziohran is Epstein.
>>

 No.499786

>>499774
Being a trump loving netanyahu escorting pedophile by association not superficial characteristic. It really is the essence of what he is.
>>

 No.499792

DSA are degenerate furry diaper porn addict. HaSSan himself. They're all implicated in diaper furry pedophile porn simply by associating with haSSan https://youtube.com/shorts/so6rSy2IWek?is=93r0gPLBr89Q_ocB
>>

 No.499800

>>499779
im not a socialist and i dont have a criticism of mamdani, my goal here is to put pressure on socialists
but just saying that reeks of being a gay copout and i should give you an example even if i dont agree with it completely so here you go

i think that mamdani represents an authentic expression of a desire for socialism
there are different kinds of socialism, at least three main camps that i can think of, and mamdani fits in what you might call the social-democratic or reformist camp
i dont think that this camp is bad, maybe electoral politics and social-democratic reforms are useful or even necessary, but they arent sufficient for socialism and always fail on their own
the reason why people like mamdani and other socdems always fuck up is that one of the main contradictions of going down a purely socdem/reformist path is that the socialist elements are dependent on the capitalist elements, so its particularly easy to force concessions
of course theyre right to point out that the political system is a plutocratic oligarchy but they cant seriously challenge it, they always end up accepting the legitimacy of capitalist politics
so its not surprising that mamdani never seriously attempted to use the power he won to do this
even just considering baby steps he couldve set a precedent to use referendums or he couldve tried to institute popular assemblies, this couldve had an effect even if it was all purely formal
in practice his socialist platform ended up just being a negotiating position to put pressure on the conservative wing of the democratic party to try and make it more "progressive" whatever that means
socialism is defined by production being subject to political decisions, so how those political decisions are made is very important, the lesson of the ussr is that while it is possible to have socialism without democracy the consequences are dire
socialists have to win the battle for democracy if they ever want a chance, what that really means is rejecting the legitimacy of the capitalist state's claim to democracy
people like mamdani (reformists who engage in electoral politics) can be useful as servants to a broader socialist movement in that battle for democracy, but they dont have a viable path to socialism on their own and are utterly awful at being leaders or even just figureheads for socialism
>>

 No.499802

>>499022
>i think that mamdani represents an authentic expression of a desire for socialism
Oh wow, this is actually way worse analysis than I thought it would be.

This is barely even a critique of Mamdani; you essentially mistake his audience and the public image presented by his electoral campaign for his actual character and role within the DNC. No, to be clear, those things are charades. And, even forgiving my nitpick that social democracy is not an actual form of socialism, it stands evident that there is no social democratic movement of any significance whatsoever within the United States today; the DNC itself has institutionally rejected any facsimile of even so much as returning to FDR-style compromise, let alone "Nordic model" economic policy. The DNC and GOP are fundamentally state institutions, and as state institutions the real interests which they always represent are those of the real state, which, in America today, is the military & corporate state of rentiers, finance capitalists, and plunderers from which the American oligarchs of today emerge. While there is street-level desire for real reform, the democratization of wealth, and the empowerment of workers in the United States, the function of "socialists" like Mamdani, Sanders, AOC, etc. is to suck the life out of any socialist, anti-zionist, anti-imperialist movement and create the illusion that today's American labor movement can and does operate within the institutional parameters set by the most bloodthirsty robber barons alive in the world today. Even if the goal was a "compromise" like social democracy, it would still never emerge under conditions where these figures are treated as legitimate, because attaining even a "compromise" requires some form of pressure from outside of institutions bought and controlled by the American corporate state.

What many critics of Mamdani have done, and I believe were probably right to do (and some examples which spring to mind immediately are Nerdeen Kiswani and BadEmpanada), was that they treated Mamdani's candidacy with an air of "cautious optimism," pointing out, from a perspective of material analysis, why such a candidacy through the DNC was unlikely to achieve any positive results, while still offering "hope" that they were wrong, and approval of the electoral messaging even though you could tell they knew it was a charade, there was a decisive humoring of it. This positioned them very well to (correctly) be ruthless in criticism leveled after the election towards Mamdani's betrayal of the anti-genocide movement he ran on, and to share in the disappointment of Mamdani's supporters in a way which underlines just how fake and disconnected Mamdani's sycophants are. They also have managed to demonstrate how a simple materialist understanding of politics, and political parties and the financial interests behind them, yields better predictions… and all of this was done without starting from a public position of bitterness or spite or aloofness. When they discuss Mamdani's betrayal of the anti-genocide movement, of the opposition to the abduction of college students by the government, or the opposition to war, they are sharing the discontentment of the public who once had hopes in Mamdani.
>>

 No.499804

>>499802
i dont care to defend the argument i gave you since like i said it was only an example and im not a socialist anyways
and im not sure if you understand why i gave it at all (or if you even read past the first few sentences considering how narrowly focused your line of argumentation is)

what sets that argument apart from pretty much all the discourse ive witnessed so far is that it asserts a positive conception of socialism
you can disagree with it and again i dont care, but i do feel compelled to point out that the meaning of socialism is contradictory, contingent and ultimately understood through practice

in other words im saying that something that is merely negative creates nothing
and if any accusation of hypocrisy feels warranted against me then i think its in saying that
>>

 No.499839


Unique IPs: 13

[Return][Go to top][Catalog]|[Home] [Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / b / WRK / hobby / tech / edu / ga / ent / music / 777 / posad / i / a / lgbt / R9K / dead ] [ meta ]
Return Catalog Top Bottom Home