[ home / overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / b / WRK / hobby / tech / edu / ga / ent / music / 777 / posad / i / a / lgbt / R9K / dead ] [ meta ]

/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"The anons of the past have only shitposted on the Internets about the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Captcha
Tor Only

Flag
File
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

Matrix   IRC Chat   Mumble

| Catalog | Home

File: 1622232000073.jpeg ( 19.03 KB , 474x314 , 4353454.jpeg )

 No.285223[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

Hello /leftypol/, we noticed an under-appreciation for the theory that upholds our political ideologies: As such, we have decided to revive the reading sticky! This thread will be dedicated to the sharing, discussing, and general banter about various leftist thinkers, theories, and political outlooks.

But, other than that, we believe there are other important reads that must be addressed, especially, for beginners and those just now getting into leftism.

Don't forget to check out >>>/edu/ for more reading and discussion!

———————
Common Right Wing Talking Points Debunks
——————–

Check out the /edu/ thread at
https://leftychan.net/edu/res/5576.html

Also see the relevant leftybooru tag
https://lefty.pictures/post/list/debunk/1
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
406 posts and 120 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.492548

>>492545
I asked this before. Allowing retards to use the reading thread to """debate""" using their faggy-ass sub-literate """libertarian""" cliches was a weird decision, and apparently purely a consequence of us just being very chill.


File: 1707073746515.jpg ( 589.82 KB , 850x954 , 15c83c5065fc60814.jpg )

 No.478400[Reply]

This thread will detail some of the changes made to the site in the past year, as well as our plans for the future.

New i2p Address
As requested by several users, and in accordance with our general ethos of encouraging online anonymity, leftychan now has an i2p address which can be found here:
http://leftychmxz3wczbd4add4atspbqevzrtwf2sjobm3waqosy2dbua.b32.i2p or http://leftychan.i2p/

Moderation Changes
* New spam filter - Thanks to the hard work of our dev and admin Zer0-, leftychan now has an effective countermeasure against the automatic bot spam that plagues alt-chans. Dubbed as the 'spam noticer', the implementation of this system has led to a dramatic fall in malicious advertisement threads being posted to the site.
* New mods & dev - In order to better cover european and asian timezones, two more mods have been voted onto the team. These are sindikat, who has previous moderation experience, and jon, who is also acting as a dev and has made many valuable contributions in this capacity.
* Removal of Zul - In line with the rule that if a mod is inactive for over 15 weeks their status as a mod is called into question, Zul was voted off the mod team.

New Roulette Board
>>>/777/
After some discussion, we decided on /k/ as the new roulette board theme, replacing /CHAD/. Archived threads from previous roulette cycles can still be viewed here >>>/roulette_archive/
Any suggestions for future roulette board rotations are welcome.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
28 posts and 3 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.492505

Ok


File: 1758948504003.jpg ( 96.42 KB , 1000x600 , grichka bogdan26.jpg )

 No.491673[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

It's coming in days. Weeks tops. Since the end of the 12 day long Imposed War, the US & Israel have been recuperating, eagerly scheming another attack on Iran since the last one backfired. The EU has played along with this scheme, collaborating with the US and Israel to restore sanctions against Iran, a continued act of aggressive economic warfare.

U.S. Secretary of "Defense" Pete Hegseth has recently called an "unprecedented" number of high ranking U.S. military officials to meet in Virginia for an undisclosed purpose, and in the same week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is scheduled to meet with U.S. President Donald Trump.

This is a thread for discussing this war as soon as it kicks off, and the lead-up to it.
581 posts and 256 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495117

🚨🇮🇷 Spokesman for the Khatim Al-Anbiya Headquarters:

In the name of Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful.

Following the 84th wave of the True Promise 4 operations, in the name of the Sahib al-Zaman, the IRGC Naval Forces carried out a surprise operation targeting several gatherings of zionist and American terrorists on Bubiyan Island (Kuwait).

Using suicide drones and ballistic missiles, many American terrorist marines were killed, and the injured were transferred to the Sabeh al-Sabah, Mohammad al-Ahmed, and Ali al-Salem hospitals.

This attack against the zionist and American soldiers will continue everywhere in this region until they are completely wiped out from Muslim lands, with Allah's grace and crushing strikes. Victory comes only from Allah the Almighty, the All-Wise.
>>

 No.495118

🇮🇷 Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps:

Sinking of tactical vessels and the killing of a large number of american terrorists in the continuation of Wave 84.

In the continuation of Wave 84 of the "True Promise 4" operation, under the blessed code name "O You who are severe in punishment," and dedicated to the artists and celebrities committed to the revolution during these nights, the IRGC Navy, through a combined attack against the zionist-american terrorists in "Shuwaikh" port and the coasts and port of Dubai, accurately struck depressed american soldiers and their tactical equipment.

In this operation, which was carried out using Ghadr 380 ballistic and cruise missiles, 6 american LCU combat landing craft in "Shuwaikh" port were struck. According to field reports, 3 of these combat ships were sunk after the strike, and the rest are burning.

Simultaneously, a drone operation was carried out against the gathering centers of the terrorist officers of the american drone unit on the coast and one of the hotels in Dubai, using attack drones, and these centers were accurately struck.

During this operation, in addition to the sinking of the tactical vessels, a large number of american terrorists were also killed. We have said before: wherever you go, we will come after you; you will be miserable.

The IRGC Navy, by the permission of Allah, with full dominance and oversight, will crushingly respond to the enemy's acts of malice.
>>

 No.495119

>>495116
Israel is actually getting rocked, good.
>>495117
>many American terrorist marines were killed
I wonder if they knew they were terrorists.
>>

 No.495121

🚨🟡🟢 BREAKING - Hezbollah:

1
After monitoring the movements of an "israeli" enemy army force near Baydar al-Faqa'ani in the town of Taybeh as it advanced down towards the Litani River bed in the Baydar al-Nahr area, the Islamic Resistance fighters lured it into a tight fire ambush at 12:30 AM on Saturday 28-03-2026 and targeted it with rocket weaponry, artillery shells, and attack drones. The ambush area turned into a kill zone, resulting in a large number of casualties in the ranks of the enemy, which is currently working to evacuate its dead and wounded under heavy fire and smoke cover, as helicopters are evacuating the casualties in the Baydar al-Faqa'ani area. The defense operation is still ongoing as of the moment this statement was issued.
>>

 No.495124

According to "israel," a missile was fired from Yemen about 10 minutes ago.


 No.485932[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

Syrian rebels enter Aleppo three days into surprise offensive
Insurgents had recaptured territory around Syria’s second city with civilians including children killed in fighting

Islamist insurgents have entered Syria’s second city of Aleppo in a shock assault, eight years after forces loyal to Damascus seized control of the city.

Fighters from Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) began a major offensive earlier this week from their base in the Idlib countryside, a slim strip of land in Syria’s north-west. It took only three days for the fighting to reach Aleppo, with insurgents capturing territory around the city’s outskirts for the first time in four years as Syrian government forces pummelled rebel-held areas.

Turkey’s Anadolu state news agency reported on Friday afternoon that the insurgents had entered Aleppo, while unverified images and video circulating online showed armoured vehicles and armed uniformed militants on its streets. The Associated Press said residents reported hearing missiles striking its outskirts.

The fighting over the last three days had killed 27 civilians, including eight children, David Carden, the UN deputy regional humanitarian coordinator for the Syria crisis, told Reuters.

The rebels have rapidly recaptured dozens of towns and villages in the Aleppo countryside, seizing a military base, weaponry and tanks from Syrian government forces, while some Turkish-backed Syrian rebel groups based elsewhere in north-west Syria joined the fighting.

The UN said Syrian government forces based in Damascus carried out at least 125 airstrikes and shelled areas across Idlib and western Aleppo controlled by the rebels in response to the offensive, killing at least 12 civilians and wounding 46 others, and displacing 14,000 people.

Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
253 posts and 51 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.494160

File: 1769759395801.jpg ( 121.83 KB , 1080x1080 , Russia withdraws from base….jpg )

Russian forces have reportedly begun a rapid withdrawal from their military outpost at Qamishli airport in north-east Syria. The pullout occurred just as Ahmed al-Sharaa arrived in Moscow for a state visit on 28 January 2026, to discuss the future of Russia's remaining military presence.

Analysts suggest Putin is sacrificing isolated outposts like Qamishli to secure long-term rights to the more vital Hmeimim airbase and Tartus naval base on Syria's Mediterranean coast. Despite the "conciliatory tone" of recent talks, Russia's continued sheltering of Bashar al-Assad in Moscow remains a major sticking point, as Sharaa has repeatedly requested his extradition.

-
MintPress News
>>

 No.494461

https://x.com/TheCradleMedia/status/2024933301321171115
"The president of Syria, who I essentially put there, is doing a phenomenal job."

During a press conference at the White House today, US President Donald Trump admits that his administration helped put unelected president Ahmad al-Sharaa into power in Syria.
>>

 No.494834

The arch-cuck strikes again:

Syrian President Abu Mohammed Al-Julani (Ahmed Al-Sharaa) calls for disarming Hezbollah from the weapons it uses to resist zionist aggression and occupation.
>>

 No.494844

File: 1773112650230.jpg ( 273.78 KB , 720x1199 , 20260309_213014.jpg )

>>

 No.495123

Explosions heard in Damascus. Explosions reported at U.S. base in Al-Hasakah, in the northeast, and:

🚨 Soldiers of Al-Karrar Brigade in the Levant:

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
"Indeed, We will take retribution from the criminals."

In support of the proud Iranian people and their valiant resistance, in support of our mujahideen brothers in the Islamic Revolutionary Guard, in defense of Islam, and in response to the sinful aggressions by America and "israel" of evil, and amidst the second phase of the operations of the fighters of the Soldiers of Al-Karrar Brigade in the Levant, we targeted "israeli" enemy gatherings in our occupied lands in the south of our country with a blessed rocket barrage on the evening of 27/03/2026. The strike was direct.

"And victory is not but from Allah, the Exalted in Might, the Wise."


 No.495082[Reply]

What do you guys think of centrists? I think that other than anti-idpol leftists, post-left anarchists and lolberts centrists are the most tolerable people to talk to. Who else do we have? Woketards? Radlibs? Christcucks? Literal fascists? Like, everyone else is kinda dumb and insane at least in some way, there isn't much to choose from. And centrists are the most popular political faction after woketards/radlibs and Christcucks/fascists.
4 posts omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495105

>>495087
>No idea why you would consider lolberts to be centrists,
I do not.
>>495091
>If you can't pick a side you're a coward.
If you pick a side you are also a coward because you gave in to peer pressure. The true gigachads are those who are not afraid to go their own way and shift allegiances when it suits them. It's neither centrism nor campism.
>>

 No.495108

>>495087
>At least people on the far right (lolberts) know that something is wrong and are willing to engage with others who think something with wrong, you can have quite productive conversations and even ally with them on specific issues.
That's fair. But you can still ally with centrists on culture war, no?
>>

 No.495109

>>495108 (me)
Also, can you blame the centrists for always choosing the middle ground when both sides are full of crazies and when moderate opinions often appear to be the more nuanced ones as a consequence of that? Culture war, AI, even immigration and wars are very, VERY polarizing topics where each side uncritically supports a certain position. It's understandable how one's kneejerk response to it all will be believing that the horseshoe theory is correct. After all, how many people even know about anti-idpol leftists? Seriously.
>>

 No.495120

>>495096
>You're not entitled to my labor value or solidarity. Solidarity is earned.
Who asked?
>It is fundamentally wrong to bring life into the world.
No its not that's just how life works. There are no wrongs or rights in the natural world.
>>

 No.495122

>>495105
>because you gave in to peer pressure.
That's retarded, there is a correct side based on the available evidence.


File: 1764565007808-0.jpg ( 369.76 KB , 1347x1679 , November 29 2025 Internati….jpg )

File: 1764565007808-1.jpg ( 126.14 KB , 559x710 , November 23 2025 Israel bo….jpg )

File: 1764565007808-3.mp4 ( 23.25 MB , 1280x720 , death to the IDF.mp4 )

 No.492498[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

Continued from >>490646

Updates and current status since the start of the last thread:
(largely civilian) Palestinian death toll has now passed 70,000. Excess deaths have been estimated by The Lancet to plausibly be upwards of 186,000.

Italian workers' unions launched a massive general strike in October over the shipping of weapons through Italian ports which are being used in Israel's genocide, and launched another strike in November.

In early January 2025, Israel agreed to a ceasefire in Gaza and a prisoner exchange. Israel unilaterally broke the ceasefire. In October 2025, another ceasefire and prisoner exchange was agreed upon in Gaza, and Israel has proceeded to kill over 300 Palestinians in Gaza since agreeing. Israel has also refused to allow the agreed-upon amount of aid into Gaza.

Israel attacked Iran utilizing a large number of assets embedded in Iran, killing multiple scientists and high ranking Iranian military officials, as well as targeting schools, hospitals, oil assets, and a TV station. Around one thousand Iranians were killed in Israel's strikes on civilian targets like residential buildings. Iran retaliated with a series of waves of missile and drone attacks which hit multiple Israeli military targets including IDF HQ, Mossad HQ, as well as an Israeli oil field. After an Iranian strike on Unit 8200, the number of online Zionist apologists conspicuously reduced for a while. The Israeli government, embarrassed by the damage to Tel Aviv, heavily censored footage and reporting of Iranian strikes on Israel, resulting in the Israeli police arresting journalists and citizens for filming sites of impact, while rich Israelis fled by boat due to the closure of Ben-Gurion airport. Iran began a crackdown on Israeli terror cells, finding and closing multiple Mossad-linked covert drone factories, as well as reportedly arresting groups of Afghan nationals involved in sabotage, and multiple individuals reportedly linked to German & Indian spy agencies.

The US launched airstrikes against multiple Iranian nuclear energy sites, followed by Iran retaliating with a strike on a US airbase in Qatar. A ceasefire between Israel and Iran has been in place since shortly after this, with expectations being that Israel intends to recouperate and try again with more direct US invoPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
302 posts and 125 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495095

What has Yemen really accomplished? Gaza's death toll is still high.
>>

 No.495097

>>495095
They effectively shut down the Port of Eilot and stopped Red Sea traffic when they were active.
That's a way bigger impact than anything anyone in the west has done so far, despite the fact the most of "israel's" munitions & tech are made & shipped from the U.S. & Europe.
>>

 No.495099

>>495097
Why do you orientalize the Exotic Other for doing surface level aesthetical resistance when more than 75,000 were killed in Gaza? What a great dent they must've made.
>>

 No.495102

🚨 The Palestinian Authority abducted the Palestinian activist and liberated prisoner, Omar Assaf.

The Committee of Families of Political Detainees in the West Bank released a statement condemning the arrest of Omar Assaf by Palestinian Authority security services in Ramallah.

The committee described the detention as a targeted suppression of national leadership and political voices. It demanded:
• The immediate release of Omar Assaf.
• The release of all political detainees held by the authority.
• An end to the practice of arrests based on political affiliation and opinion.

The committee called on national factions to intervene to protect public freedoms while confronting the occupation.

Omar Assaf has always been a voice defending all oppressed people. He consistently participated in demonstrations in support of Gaza and its resistance.

In one interview he stated “We are one people. What harms Gaza harms the West Bank. All the Palestinian people are with Gaza and the resistance, and any voices that are not with the resistance are outliers from the will and spirit of our people. Any voice that emerges to blame the resistance is a suspicious voice, only serving the enemies of our people, the occupation and its allies.”
>>

 No.495111

File: 1774665329017.jpg ( 151.76 KB , 1278x1049 , IMG_20260327_223042_663.jpg )

Within Our Lifetime's Nerdeen Kiswani was recently informed by the FBI that a plot against her life was about to take place. Torn on this one between my distrust of the FBI and my keen awareness that Betar has been threatening her for years at this point.


File: 1772897537331.png ( 2.46 MB , 1200x1118 , liberals.png )

 No.494799[Reply]

the community actually needs a place to live
6 posts omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495037

https://www.cpusa.org/article/rise-in-unity-for-democracy-and-our-future/
>Rise in unity for democracy and our future – Communist Party USA

"Housing for people, not profit

Housing is a human right which requires removing the profit motive. Affordable housing, built and maintained with union labor, must be created for renters and homeowners. Rents and mortgages should be immediately rolled back to no more than 30% of income with the goal of pushing housing costs below 10% of income. We need to enact national rent control with protections against evictions and foreclosures. More public housing must be built with first priority to the unhoused. Profiteering by banks and private equity firms must be stopped. The time to organize tenant unions is now!"
>>

 No.495038

>>495037
Now remember to vote Democrat. We have to stop Trump!
>>

 No.495088

File: 1774555671952.mp4 ( 16.75 MB , 720x1280 , EggGodNeedsMorePublicHousi….mp4 )

>>

 No.495089

>>495088
What are you trying o communicate with this video, anon?
>>

 No.495090

>>495089
How would you feel if you didn't eat breakfast this morning?


File: 1774186416232.png ( 755.42 KB , 1729x1215 , IMG_3312.png )

 No.495039[Reply]

I see a lot of talk concerning how Israel should be supported by the USA and European countries for various reasons and, notably, none of them concern with material benefits for either native Europeans or long-time American citizens, instead focusing on abstractions and ideals. As Trump has led the USA into another forever war with Iran (at the behest of Israel, per the words of US Secretary of State Marco Rubio), it is pertinent to talk about a common anti-Zionist talking point that I find counterproductive. Namely: Israel’s colonialism is the same as that of American settle colonialism from the late 18thcentury to the early 20th century.

This is incorrect as, while America is a settler-colonial state, nonetheless was founded on the basis of enlightenment principles like equality before the law and liberty, considering how the American and French revolutions at the time were leftist at the time of the events, with the notion of equality of men itself being already extremely radical at a time when absolute monarchies were the standard in Europe. That’s not all, as contrary to popular opinion the Founding Fathers themselves weren’t conservative. Whether it’s the lack of any mention specifying the USA as a “white Christian country” founded on the basis of theology in the constitution and the federalist papers, George Washington himself coming to oppose slavery before the abolitionist movement began to gain momentum, many of said fathers being at best deists or nominally Christian, the USA being effectively the first democratic republic in history with limited suffrage being a short-lived experiment that was swept away in favour of universal male suffrage, Thomas Jefferson himself owning a copy of the Quran and a version of the Bible excised of all supernatural elements and among other examples show that the USA was far from the hotbed of reactionary politics both liberals and chuds tend to portray it as. Even the Indian Removal Act that led to the infamous “Trail of Tears” wasn’t unanimously agreed upon, with strong opposition by Christian missionaries and other politicians who opposed it based on the shared humanity and parity between white settlers Native Americans.

So it’s no wonder given all this that, despite the reproduction of reactionary politics like Manifest Destiny and Jim Crow laws, the notion of equality (or pretence to it) persisted throughout American history, which laid the seeds for the civil rights, feminist, and gay rightPost too long. Click here to view the full text.
4 posts omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495048

>>495045
Oh wow he freed a few slaves after winning an entire war fought to preserve it. Truly a great man.
>>

 No.495049

>ITT Honkies recognizing Israeli settler colonialism while continuing to fail to recognize their own perpetuated on Blacks and indigenous peoples.
Top kek
>>

 No.495080

>>495046
Jefferson at least wanted a new constitution every 19 years. If not democratic, it is at least populist. Although probably next to impossible to actually enact kek it would take 17 years of drafting each time


But yeah, there are no elections in a democracy. Every government position, from senator on down to public librarian, should be determined by lot. This is how it was in ancient Athens, which would be considered a democracy if it wasn't for the massive amount of slaves and total lack of rights for women.
>>

 No.495081

>>

 No.495083

>>495080
Athens did have some elected offices. They were the ten military generals and many offices dealing with finance. The general sentiment though, as outlined by Aristotle, is that elections were oligarchic in nature. In fact the popular opinion on this was so coherent that it was actually a justification for making financial offices elected: if someone who handles money embezzles money while in office, that money could later be reclaimed from their estate.


 No.483853[Reply][Last 50 Posts]

Party declaration:
https://x.com/ACPMain/status/1815163785134436404

The American Communist Party (ACP) is an organization which aims to reconstitute the historic Communist Party USA, which has become corrupted by federal agents and liberal forces. Look no further than Joe Sims, who supports the genocidal Democratic Party. It was launched in July of 2024, in response to the events of the 32nd Convention of the CPUSA. At this convention, party leadership subverted and betrayed democratic centralism and the freedom of critique which is supposed to follow from it. They claimed to be a genuine Marxist-Leninist party, but the leadership doesn't even follow their own rules. The CPUSA delayed all elections and without a vote made a resolution that they’d basically just campaign for Democrats. Just a bunch of boomers sitting around and writing articles about identity politics rather than organizing.

Already the ACP is far more successful than anyone would have expected from a brand new baby party. They are building reputation locally, taking care of their own communities and making areas safe for children and families to enjoy. Diplomatic ties on the international level have already been established. ACP has garnered more attention in the past couple months than the corrupt, decadent CPUSA leadership has in decades. A huge number of the CPUSA clubs across the entire country had a huge part in making this happen. Will you join up?

Website:
https://acp.us/
238 posts and 49 image replies omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495012

>>495006
>centered around making successful small businesses
No they don't do that. I don't even think they sell merch unlike .org.
Each chapter funds their own activity. And they seem to do both activist work and community charity work to build rapport with the people. And what else do you want them to do? How are they going to grow if you refuse to help?
>>

 No.495013

>>495011
>The problem is class, not one porky or the other.
The guy you're replying to knows this and was being sarcastic.
>placing capitalists and capitalism at the heart of their funding structure
how come I don't know about this? I literally thought it was like how I explained here: >>495012 (me)
>>

 No.495014

>>495010
>they should just rely on billionaire donations and shit
never said that, it's just that if you get your money mostly from small business stuff.. won't your communist party just be full of petit bourgeois?
>scroll through this page and tell me when you see any mention of transgenders
here is their chairman ranting about the troons >>484011
id prefer if they didn't mention them at all to be honest
>>

 No.495067

>>495014
>won't your communist party just be full of petit bourgeois?
lenin had no problem making use of the peasantry and party cadre do not need to be proles. what is the strategic logic behind not trying to gain some financial independence so that surplus value that could be used for funding would not get extracted?
>here is their chairman ranting about the troons
you got a tweet from haz 3 years ago before acp was even a thing
>id prefer if they didn't mention them at all to be honest
they dont unless they get demonized for not caring again
>>

 No.495068

>>495067
also acp businesses are meant to be workers cooperative enterprises integrated into the larger logic of the party


File: 1767941769437.mp4 ( 1.63 MB , 576x1048 , VID_stairs.mp4 )

 No.493465[Reply]

What is the difference between a cop shooting you in the face, and a gang member shooting you in the face? What makes the former 'legit' and the latter 'criminal'?

Has there ever been one example in human history of that invisible entity calling itself 'government' that didn't exist outside of its self-declared right to kill you if you didn't do what it said? That a tiny minority (or even one single person) one day declaring "I am in charge, now. Bow down or I'll murder you." and everybody else inexplicably nodding and going along with this psychotic nonsense?

I'm not being an anarchist nor a lolbert. I fully understand the need for this objectively nonsensical situation in order for humanity to function and prosper. Without somebody holding a bigger stick than someone else, that someone else has no reason to behave himself.

And there is no stick bigger than God.

There wouldn't be ~3 billion Christians and Muslims if somebody didn't convince them all (with violence) that if they misbehaved that after they died an invisible sky fairy would exercise incalculable sadism by trapping them in trillion-degree lava for the rest of time.

And the only reason that this schizophrenic idea stuck is that somebody with a big stick told everyone else that "this bronze age book of barbaric bedtime stories is all true and in fact nothing is more true than it, so do what it says or I'll kill you AND THEN you will 'die the second death' by being trapped in trillion-degree lava until the end of time".

What is the point of this OP? Nothing, really. Just had this on my mind while lamenting that existence in its current form was a ghastly mistake, if there really is some sort of unmoved mover and ground of all things that created it. And that if there is no outside-of-time-and-physicality lawmaker behind the invisible concepts we call the laws of nature, that all there has ever been and all that there ever will be is a fully-automatic universe consisting of incomprehensibly small bits and bobbles bouncing around in the cosmic void, then there is no such thing outside of things, that what we call "concepts" are just us trying to cast invisible nets around invisible nonsense to try and make sense of an ultimately senseless existence.
1 post omitted. Click reply to view.
>>

 No.495042

>>493465
>There wouldn't be ~3 billion Christians…
Islam is another story, but this is actually quite ahistorical for Christianity. Christianity wasn't a state-sanctioned religion until several centuries after its founding. Before that its growth was largely voluntary and early Christians had a communal outlook.
>>

 No.495044

>>493465
OP Fuck your AI slop. But also yes, government is a monopoly on violence. The only difference between a socialist government and a capitalist one is who the government is oppressing. Yes you can still get arrested for bullshit you don't agree with under socialism, but at least they will use cops to oppress the bourgeoisie primarily and prevent a reversion back to capitalism.

Nobody knows what happens next. We probably need almost every country to have a socialist revolution before the state can wither away. But I don't like to think too far into the future, things are so fucked in America that we should really take it week by week with some sort of outlook.
>>

 No.495054

>>495044
>but at least they will use cops to oppress the bourgeoisie primarily and prevent a reversion back to capitalism
One can only hope. Sadly most of the socialist governments of the 20th century simply brought the bourgeoisie class into the state apparatus. When you eliminate the undemocratic work arrangements that create the basis of class in the first place, you don't need cops to suppress the bourgeoisie.
>>

 No.495065

It's telling that the only way human society can be conceived is the rule of a particular method of violence asserted for no reason worth considering, and this is seen as wholly natural and automatic. You have to ask if it was always like this, and usually you conclude that it was not, yet not one example against it is "real". Even when the violence is nowhere near what it purports to be and does not have the power it claims, the assertion of arbitrary violence and cruelty is the only Law humans ever regard or grant spiritual authority, because they really don't know anything else.

If this is about a self-declared right to kill, any idiot can claim that. I can get in my car and use it as a weapon for some vehicular murder, and suddenly I'm "God" according to that theory. Whether you kill by direct violence or by habitual lying and institutions that make it "automatic", it's always reduced to the essential acts of killing and torture and never about anything good or useful. Everyone who tried to assemble something on any other basis is immediately attacked, denounced, and edited out of history, even though we know such a thing would be trivial and non-controversial. It would be very easy to not do any of this, but if we did, suddenly the people who did this to you whine about a "human spirit" and "human nature" that they have already declared a monopoly over.

At the end of all of it, nothing really gets done. The real government of humanity, or what counts as such, is always conducted in secret. This is thrown in front of your face and every institution we have ever known exists to laugh at you as you're ejected from the world. You might think this is a modern thing, but if you look at the past and are not trapped by the fetters you are exhorted to believe are "natural", the Roman system was remarkably similar. The Romans didn't even bother lying about it, and Roman historians will tell you it was a bunch of shit from start to finish. Nowhere do the Romans invoke anything like ideology or justice when it came to the purpose of the state. The purpose of the Roman state was to preserve slavery, and it's written in the legal code. The most humanistic Roman leaders would tell you why the state exists, without any glorification of the idea of the state. That perversion is a modern, Germanic invention that has nothing to do with the Law of any country that was at all functional. Yet, here we are, where the only idea permitted is a glorification Post too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>

 No.495066

File: 1774352845132.jpg ( 13.18 KB , 160x389 , thorazine.jpg )



Delete Post [ ]
[ home / overboard / sfw / alt / cytube] [ leftypol / b / WRK / hobby / tech / edu / ga / ent / music / 777 / posad / i / a / lgbt / R9K / dead ] [ meta ]
Previous [ 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 7 / 8 / 9 / 10 / 11 / 12 / 13 / 14 / 15 / 16 / 17 / 18 / 19 / 20 / 21 / 22 / 23 / 24 / 25 / 26 / 27 / 28 / 29 / 30 / 31 / 32 / 33 / 34 / 35 / 36 ]
| Catalog | Home