>>477615No, credit where credit is do, John Mearsheimer's takes are grounded in reality, even if we don't agree on ideology.
>FFS you can be anti-Israel and also acknowledge that Hamas pulled some sick shit on October 7.I'm not necessarily opposed to Israel, i'm opposed to Zionism, because its fascist(Marxist definition) in ideology and praxis. At least in theory Israel could be a "normal" country without the apartheid mega-death bullshit.
A violent reaction to the inhuman conditions in Gaza is universal to the human species, if there wasn't
a Hamas there would be something else. Ultimately the Zionists created the conditions for OCT7 and i think they should get the blame. You certainly can't blame the Palestinians, they aren't granted rights and protections, hence they don't have obligations either. This is not a one-way street, the Zionists do not get to impose uncivilized conditions on Palestinians and still demand civilized conduct in return. If you create good material conditions for people you get peaceful people with a pleasant attitude. If you create horrible material conditions for people, you get violent and unpleasant people. It's not realistic to expect anything else. Consider that most Palestinians alive today, never experienced peace, their entire life has been war, their entire live has been an experience that political agency flows from the bomb-bay of a fighter jet.
There is another disturbing political current that i wish to oppose. There are people who try to harm others by weaponizing the environment, and that can't get a pass. A historic example would be Malthus from the 1800s, he advocated to create unsanitary conditions in the poor-people districts in order to encourage more death among the poor. The Zionists have also tried to kill Palestinians via a weaponized environment.
Of course I would much prefer if there was a secular communist resistance that embodied enlightenment values in Gaza instead of Hamas with backwards religious stuff. But there's no point in complaining, there already are more than enough armchair communists complaining about how other people are struggling wrong.
Also the Zionists went too far and they have now become "Tätervolk", and no longer count as "Opfervolk" in the Political framing.
"Tätervolk" translates to perpetrator-people
"Opfervolk" translates to victimized-people
What this means for the political decorum, can be explained by an example from WW2. There is no expectation that when we talk about the Holocaust that we also have to acknowledge the Dresden terror bombings. In the same vein we can talk about the genocide of the Palestinians as a stand alone event without having to acknowledge OCT7.
But all of what i just said is nothing but irrelevant academic masturbation anyway. The Zionists have declared that all Palestinians (including unborn babies) are Hamas, so even if i shared your opinion, i couldn't condemn Hamas because it would be advocacy for collective punishment against all Palestinians.