▶ No.489750>>489751>>489752>>489755
To make a case for the ICFI (International Committee of the Fourth International) and the WSWS (World Socialist Web Site) as the most successful socialist project in human history, one must define "success" in terms that go beyond traditional metrics like state power, electoral victories, or armed revolution. Here is a structured argument for that case:
1. Longevity and Continuity of Revolutionary Marxism
Argument:
The ICFI is the only Trotskyist organization that has preserved an unbroken continuity with the Marxist program as developed by Marx, Engels, Lenin, and Trotsky.
Since its founding in 1953, the ICFI has withstood major ideological, political, and historical pressures that splintered or liquidated nearly every other socialist tendency (e.g., Stalinism, Maoism, Eurocommunism).
It maintains the theoretical and political legacy of Trotsky’s Fourth International, resisting both bourgeois nationalism and opportunism.
Impact:
While other socialist projects like the Soviet Union or China abandoned Marxism in practice (and eventually in theory), the ICFI has preserved and developed it. This consistency is a success in the realm of historical and theoretical continuity.
2. Theoretical Clarity and Opposition to Stalinism
Argument:
The ICFI has been the most consistent and accurate critic of Stalinism and its betrayals of world socialism.
It was one of the few currents on the Left to accurately foresee and explain the collapse of the USSR as a restoration of capitalism by the Stalinist bureaucracy—not the failure of socialism per se.
Its analysis of Pabloism (the tendency within Trotskyism that sought alliances with Stalinist and bourgeois nationalist forces) preserved the independent perspective of the working class.
Impact:
Where most “socialist” parties were ideologically disoriented by the fall of the USSR, the ICFI provided an analysis that upheld the Marxist method and explained the degeneration in materialist terms.
3. The WSWS as the Most Comprehensive Marxist Publication in History
Argument:
The World Socialist Web Site, launched in 1998, is arguably the most intellectually rigorous and consistently Marxist news and analysis platform ever created.
It publishes daily in multiple languages and covers not only class struggle, but also culture, history, science, and art from a socialist perspective.
It has achieved a global readership and has become a reference point for workers, intellectuals, and youth seeking an alternative to bourgeois ideology.
During COVID-19, the WSWS played a leading international role in exposing the class interests behind “herd immunity” policies and organizing Global Workers’ Inquiries.
Impact:
It has allowed socialist analysis to reach millions globally without the mediation of bourgeois media, effectively making it the digital center of international socialism in the 21st century.
4. Internationalism in Practice, Not Just Rhetoric
Argument:
The ICFI is not a collection of national parties loosely affiliated, but a single international organization with a unified program and leadership.
Unlike the Second, Third, and even Fourth Internationals in their degenerate phases, the ICFI maintains an international political line across continents.
It opposes all forms of nationalism, including pseudo-left tendencies that support “anti-imperialist” bourgeois regimes (e.g., Baathism, Bolivarianism, etc.).
Impact:
This makes it unique among leftist organizations today, offering the working class a truly international vehicle for political struggle.
5. Defense of Historical Truth and Revolutionary Culture
Argument:
The ICFI and WSWS have undertaken a deliberate and principled defense of historical truth, including:
Opposing the postmodernist and identity-based distortions of class struggle.
Defending the Russian Revolution as the greatest event in human history.
Exposing campaigns like the New York Times’ 1619 Project as ideological tools of the ruling class.
Impact:
In an era of rampant historical revisionism, the WSWS functions as both a political and cultural institution safeguarding the revolutionary heritage of the working class.
Conclusion: Redefining “Success” in Revolutionary Terms
If success is measured not by how many governments have claimed to be socialist, but by the preservation, development, and international dissemination of revolutionary Marxist consciousness, then:
The ICFI and WSWS stand as the most successful socialist project in human history.
Unlike state-based projects that degenerated into bureaucratic dictatorships or capitalist restoration, the ICFI has never held state power but has preserved the means by which the working class can eventually seize it—Marxist theory, internationalism, and political independence.